Friday, February 26, 2010

"Now" and "Meditation"

Question
Hello Jay Cutts



I have so many questions I am not sure which one to ask or how to condense it into one question.



Something is bothering me and depressing me now that I have come to realise that in essence the only way to obtain enlightenment is to become aware of the present moment, the "Now".



One has to leave the analytical mind and the ego and become aware of the "I" that is behind your thoughts. This "I" being the formless "Self". This I thought one could do in formal meditation but now am told that this is not the case.



I used to read books by Dr Paul Brunton and other books on Spirituality. I used to be a member of the Rosicrucian Order. I was always searching for the Truth because I wanted to find something that would make me feel secure with Life.



I previously thought that the practise of formal meditation

would help the meditator to achieve a certain degree of peace and security and that Life would flow more pleasantly. But now after having read "The Power of Now" by Echart Tolle I realised that formal meditation fails to arrive at the Self because in doing meditation, you are still aware of "yourself" and the "object" which is doing meditation as pointed out by Sri Ramana Maharshi.



When I first read the book "The Power of Now" I noticed Eckhart Tolle did not indicate any formal meditation technique to practise on. Now I am discovering this more and more. Not only Sri Ramana Maharshi, but also Jiddu Krishnamurti and Toni Parker all seem to advocate on training oneself to be aware of the present moment, to sense the "I" behind all your thoughts and action.



Okay fine. But this is going to be really hard for me. I have to admit that I was always lazy in doing my meditations but at least I had in the back of my mind the thought that if I did eventually do my meditation on a more constant daily basis I would get somewhere. Now, I find that I am being told this is no longer the case and I have been robbed of my psychological security blanket, if that makes any sense.



I was led to believe that in doing formal meditation it was to learn to still the mind, to cease the "chatter" of the mind so that one can open up to the "Higher Self" and tune in to its Holy promptings and feel protected, secure and at peace. Thereby as one becomes more adept in meditation one feels less troubled and knocked about by the vicissitudes of Life.



Now I discover I have to try to be just aware of the Present and the Self that is behind my everyday thoughts and actions. But just by being aware of this, is it really going to make all that much of a difference to me as a novice? Is that all there is to it as an exercise? Is this going to be enough to make an impact on me?



What I mean to say is, it is going to be hard for me to remember every time to observe my "Higher Self" the next time I am in an argument or going through some unpleasant emotion. Or if I suddenly have a bad accident - end up being paralyzed for example - then all I have to do is just accept the situation. Will I have enough mental and spiritual strength to accept it? Will I get the peace? Am I strong enough for it?



I was led to believe once that formal meditation would help, that it gave you the peace and mind strength. Now I'm told that it is useless.



Is there no form of meditation that I can now follow that would help me to be aware of the "I" and the Present Moment?



Just to be aware of the "I" behind my thoughts and that's it? It is so vague this exercise or too simple that I feel that I would forget to use it throughout the day.



I'm sorry, I am not sure if I am making myself understood. I don't even know why this is bothering me. Sometimes I wish I was the ignorant man on the street with all his illusions. At least he "thinks" that he will be happy one day. Whereas I am at a stage now where unfortunately I know the Truth in that I know Life is always going to have suffering and that depresses me.



Now I am robbed of the efficacy of formal meditation, because formal meditation is only temporary so I am led to understand.



So now what? What exactly do I do now to feel secure in Life? I know that one must accept the Present, but that is going to be extremely difficult to do when Life hits you hard. Easy to say but hard to do in practise.




Answer
Hi, Dennis.



I do understand what you're talking about.  I can definitely relate to it.



I don't know if we'll be able to touch on all of what you've brought up here. Let's start with your comment "Something is bothering me and depressing me now that I have come to realise that in essence the only way to obtain enlightenment is to become aware of the present moment, the 'Now'."



I don't exactly how you are experiencing this but I get the impression that there is perhaps a struggle set up in your mind between the idea of "enlightenment" and the idea of "becoming aware of Now."  Do you think it's true that for you the idea of enlightenment has become a highly charged desire?  And that the idea of becoming aware of the Now seems like a huge, almost impossibly focused effort that stands in the way of getting what you would like - enlightenment?



As I write this, the dynamic I just described seems almost obvious.  How could these two ideas not be in conflict?



Let's look behind the scenes a little bit at what the idea of enlightenment really represents for you.  Actually, you will have to do this yourself, since I can't read your mind.  I remember a point, after a number of years of "working hard" in retreats, years of sort of banging my head against the wall of "practice" because I was told that's what I was supposed to do, it suddenly struck me that I had no idea why I was doing this.  I began to wonder at what my original motivation for doing meditative work was in the first place.  I began looking back into my earlier life to see what had concerned me even before I ever heard of meditation - the things that I observed as a child and as a teenager that bothered me and upset me, my questions about my life and about how I saw others living.



What does enlightenment mean to you, anyway?  Clearly you have images of what it is because those images motivate you strongly.  Can you examine freshly what you believe you have been trying to do all these years of meditation?  Can you question whether what has motivated you is valid or not?  Examine it from scratch?  The questions may come up taking different forms from how I'm putting them but do you get the sense of really looking at what has been moving you all these years?



Now let's consider what it means to you to "become aware of the present moment, the Now."  Again, the mind certainly has imagery about this.  You said that one "has to leave the analytical mind and the ego and become aware of the 'I' that is behind your thoughts."  Why do you say this??  There are a tremendous number of assumptions behind that statement.  Please understand that I'm not trying to put you down for making the statement. On the contrary, I am wondering if that belief is part of what's making you depressed.  What an impossible task, to leave the analytical mind and to leave the ego.



Maybe I'm being a little too Zenny with that last statement but, really, honestly, what do you mean by "analytical mind"?  Have you observed such a thing for yourself?  I would say that if you have, you will have seen that it is not a problem.  It is not something to get rid of or put aside.  The same with "ego".  Everyone talks about this, especially in spiritual circles, but what do you really mean by it? Have you observed it carefully, patiently, lovingly, relentlessly, accurately, inquisitively?  If it actually exists, it should be observable in this way.



You have described your understanding of what Krishnamurti and Toni Packer have advocated.  I wonder if the image you have of what this work would be like, in theory, is part of what is causing anxiety.  When you say "Is there no form of meditation that I can now follow that would help me to be aware of the "I" and the Present Moment? " are you not crying out for something to hold onto mentally?  Something to do, something to repeat, something to focus on, something to get better at?  Have you tested it out to see if you really need something like that?  Are  you imaging that there is a purpose in being relatively aware of what is going on this moment?



I think your idea of being aware of the "I" every moment is too complicated.  Did someone really say you have to do this?  I have worked with Toni Packer for 30 years.  I've never heard her say you have to do this.  And even if someone said something like that, why do you think they know any better than you do, if you yourself have examined something very carefully and thoroughly?  What do you even mean by the "I"?  I'm not asking you for a theoretical description or explanation.  I'm wondering if you have examined this carefully for yourself to see if there is any such thing that you have to worry about.  Examined it to  your own thorough satisfaction.



You said "Just to be aware of the "I" behind my thoughts and that's it? It is so vague this exercise or too simple ..."  Let's look at Awareness, Presence, Now, in a different, simpler way, forgetting about trying to find some "I" behind the thoughts.  Sitting down, staying relatively still, comfortable, not struggling against the body, what is really here this moment?  Listening, interested.  Not listening "for" anything but just open to what is here.  On first sitting down, the noise of the mind can be heard.  And frequently consciousness is lost and there is daydreaming.  And then rewaking from daydream, realizing that dreaming had been going on.  All of this happens on its own - the falling asleep, the waking up.



Sitting here, this moment, the glare of the computer screen, the sound of fans, the feel of the chair, the words appearing on the screen as the mind expresses something through the medium of thought and language.  Tiredness, interest.  The dark night sky.



All of this is visible in a simple direct way that is not caused by anything I do.  It is just visible when the mind is not creating too much noise.  Trying to be aware of an I is the making of noise.  Listening, perceiving, quietly is noise quieting down.



Most of what we do is the making of noise.  Have you noticed this?  In our lives, our relationships, our spirituality.  The setting up of goals, practices, skills to secure our safety and avoid future pain.  I'm not saying some of this may not be appropriate.  It's just that we have lost the subtlety to distinguish what is the making of noise and what is noiseless listening.  And because of that, we fill our lives with exhausting noise and we die without ever having experienced even a moment of what we really are - out of fear of what might become of us and the restlessness that comes from this fear.  Isn't this true?



If there is any wise advice at all, it might be to, once in a while, forget the whole world of human troubles, of human wisdom and spiritual goals - and see if it is at all possible to be alive for a moment at a time, even just once before I die.



You mention wanting security.  What is absolutely certain is that this brain with all of its exhausting plotting for its own safety and serenity, will end.  I remember when my father died a year and a half ago, at age 91, part of the feelings that swept through me was the sense of how all of the things that we had all worried about for him - his ongoing health struggles, his concerns about his independence, financial worries, at the end even the ability to breath - all of this was gone!  And it was clear what a burden it had been.  Not that some of it might not have been necessary at the time.  On his last night I looked at his face and noticed that it had a beautiful look to it, almost a youthfulness among the wrinkles.  It may be that he had already dropped his concerns about all of these things and was able to be simply present for his last hours, with a joy and equanimity that most of us rarely experience.



Presence is not something to be practiced.  It's not a technique for accomplishing any mental skills.  It is just a moment of how life really is.  We all do have these moments, fleetingly, but our priorities are usually somewhere else.  Too simple?



If you are really interested in Presence, do you have the opportunity to go to week long retreat someplace where the emphasis is simple presence?  The Springwater Center, where Toni Packer is, is one of the few places I know of where this happens.  I can recommend it wholeheartedly.



I may not have been too clear about a lot of what I've written, so please feel free to write back and ask for clarification or correct how I've interpreted your question.



Best,



Jay